Mike Scott Thomson
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Short Fiction
  • Non Fiction
  • Contact

Short Stories - Reading, Writing, Submitting...

12/9/2012

 
Further to my previous blog post, I should add – and it’s a point long overdue – that I also write short stories because I love the form. To read each one is to enter a new world, with its own complexities of character and situation, concentrated all within a twenty minute read or less. They can be as absorbing, if not more so, than many full length novels.

This year I have been greedily gobbling up as many as I can find – in anthologies, websites, magazines and journals – so much so, in fact, that I wonder whether I should give each one time to settle in my mind before moving on to the next one. A good short story should indeed be powerful: capable of packing a full punch that any good novel would be capable of, but within only a few thousand words. The test for me, I think, is how much I can remember of it two to three days after finishing, and whether the emotional ups and downs, or conflict, of the story has stayed lodged in my consciousness. Thus maybe a little ‘absorbing’ time after I finish each one may be in order. If I can withstand the temptation, that is…

One thing I don’t want to do here is to analyse, at least any more than my somewhat unoriginal attempt above, what makes a good short story. It’s been done so many times already, not least in the prefaces of the various anthologies I’ve been reading, that this overdose of advanced literary theory has made my head spin. Character driven vs plot driven; implied vs explicit; the power of words left unsaid vs too much information; what makes a cliché and how to avoid them; using metaphor to discern the difference in style and technique between short stories and novels; even line graphs to illustrate plot arcs. There’s so much that’s been said that I don’t think I could add any more.

As a writer, I’m still trying to find my way. Admittedly, this is mostly by making mistakes and learning from feedback, either from my writers’ groups or from competition/rejection post-mortems. Also, of course, from reading, reading, reading, and seeing what other writers are doing well and how I can learn from them – plus comparing and contrasting the different anthologies and competition results to see what one editor/judge may like. What do they think makes a good short story, as opposed to another editor/judge?

It’s interesting to see how opinions differ. One judge of a recent short story competition bemoaned the entrants who tried to do ‘too much’ within a mere three thousand words, with the fast pace leaving him exhausted (sure enough, the winning stories were all tales where, to be quite honest, nothing much happened at all – and therein lay the art of them).

Yet, another anthology I’ve been reading (namely, "Stories", edited by Neil Gaiman and Al Sarrantonio) worked to the brief that each story should make the reader ask themselves "And then what happened?" To my mind this implies the opposite; they wanted page turners, ergo, a bit of pace and, dare I say it, action. OK, they were skilfully done, and each one works perfectly within the short story form – but I wonder whether any of them would have been rated in that aforementioned competition.

That’s not to say one’s right and one’s wrong, of course. As a previous commenter on my blog has mentioned, if you’re a writer and wish to be published (or win a competition), it’s about targeting your story to an editor or judge who may actually like it. If that needs research, then so be it – i.e. if I see a competition, recognise the name of the judge, know his/her style or the sorts of stories he/she’s rated in competitions before, then I’ll have a much better idea what to submit of my own. Likewise, with anthologies, having read volumes of them over the past few months, I have (I hope) a fairly good idea of the kind of stories which may go down well in those volumes, and will target them accordingly.

I hear a lot about competition judges and anthology editors who complain about submissions written by authors who have clearly never read anything in their catalogues before. And – I will hold my hands up here – this would have been me, in the distant past. Crazy, rookie mistake – and not one I will make again.
This more considered approach is starting to pay off, both in terms of confidence in my own writing and acceptances, which is slowly but surely creeping upwards.
Picture
I’ve listed here some of the publishers of short story anthologies I’ve been reading and enjoying over the past year – all are quality and well worth checking out. For the purposes of brevity rather than more Luddite tendencies, I have only mentioned those which are available to be perused as those satisfyingly tangible pre-Internet binded papery flappy things – otherwise known as ‘books’. (Although a few are available for your Kindle, or what-have-you.)

If you have any recommendations for me, please leave a comment!

The Fiction Desk

Unthank Books

Riptide Journal

Cinnamon Press

Earlyworks Press

Salt Publishing

Comma Press

Short Fiction Journal

Eibonvale Press

Competition anthologies of prizewinners/shortlisted entrants from the Bridport Prize, Bristol Prize and Willesden Herald
​

Not read yet but high on my shopping list: prizewinning anthologies from Biscuit Publishing and Fish Publishing

Comments are closed.

    Archives

    June 2020
    October 2019
    August 2019
    June 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    October 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    December 2017
    October 2017
    June 2017
    March 2017
    November 2016
    September 2016
    April 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    January 2015
    October 2014
    June 2014
    April 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012

    Categories

    All
    1000 Words
    Berko Speakeasy
    Bridge House
    Competitions
    Dreamscape Press
    Feedback
    Five Stop Story
    Flash Fiction
    Haverthorn
    InkTears
    Litro
    Live Event
    Momaya Press
    National Flash Fiction Day
    Nine Realms
    Prize Winning
    Prole
    Publication
    Read A Story Online
    Riptide Journal
    Short Story
    Storgy
    Stories For Homes
    Strange Bounce
    The Fiction Desk
    The Red Line
    The Yarn
    To Hull & Back
    Twitter
    Visual Verse
    Writers' Forum
    Writers' Village
    Writing Advice
    Writing Challenges

Mike Scott Thomson © 2020